Showing posts with label Bravo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bravo. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Jay McCarroll on Episode One of Project Runway, Season Six

How fantastic! My favorite Project Runway winner, Jay McCarroll, wrote a recap of the Project Runway premiere this season. He did it for Marie Claire. It appears that other winners and finalists will be writing recaps throughout the season. I'll be posting links to the recaps weekly. This one has Jay's usual colorful commentary that made us love him and that is totally Jay. Take a read. Let's hope he is one who writes the majority of the recaps, they will probably be the funniest ones.

Jay McCarroll on Episode One of Project Runway, Season Six

Posted using ShareThis

Monday, August 24, 2009

Top Chef Masters: Confused by the Winner, But Still Great

It was sort of easy to tell by the edited judges table who would be the winner. Michael and Hubert had their positive critiques first and their negative critiques second, and Rick's was the reverse, that's almost always a giveaway on here. Leave you feeling positive about the winner and all. Yeah. I've been watching since the first season, you pick up a few tells that way.:)

But I was left wondering why didn't Michael win. Not because I like Michael (I do!) but because his non spectacular dish (which was not deemed to be good not great) wasn't criticized as harshly as Rick's non spectacular dish (which was heavily criticized) and Michael had excellent other dishes as Rick did. I guess mole trumps short ribs, but not sure. But coming off of the table where everyone ate, it seemed like Michael was the more likely winner. And by the end, I still wasn't sure why Rick would get it except that they were so wowed by the mole sauce. I wonder if they were tied and had to pick who won it all and edit accordingly? Just wondering. Cause like the real tool critic, the one from Saveur, he basically switched up his comments at the final judging table. His insulting 3.5 stars was woefully out of place as well. He had a problem with the polenta? Really? When was that? He said the fish interpretation wasn't complex enough, nothing about the polenta. It was odd is all. No big deal that Rick won, but they probably should have edited a bit more closely to show why Rick truly edged out Michael and Hubert. Because from what they showed, they loved Rick's other dishes but he really missed on his future dish with the different pieces of the seafood and the air thing. So, yeah, a little confused, but happy for all three to making it this far and having such a nice showing at the finale.

And since the regular season of Top Chef has begun, let me add, I don't know why Padma is a judge. A host sure, but a judge, no. I wonder this every season. And she showed in this Top Chef Masters finale one of the reasons why I tend to question her actually offering her opinion and its just one of many times I've heard her say something when I wished she would just have remained silent or at the very least consider what she was saying. Mexican food doesn't always get the street cred? Really Padma? Since what you are trying to say was Mexican food is overlooked in the world of fine dining and sophistication, "street cred" would be the last thing you would say. But I digress.

Congrats to Rick Bayless on his Top Chef Masters win. The episode may not have shown totally why you won, but you showed throughout the last several weeks that you were deserving of the title. So, Congrats!!!

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Tim Gunn is Back! Project Runway Premieres Tonight

The Naked Cowboy helps Project Runway models promote on a bus in Times Square, NYC

Project Runway is back! I am excited that its back. I'm not someone who was mad about Bravo developing a rival show, nor did I think Fashion Show was that bad. Here's the thing. Project Runway wants me to take their side in this? Or more accurately, their production company and Lifetime? Please! That's like saying it was okay for the Baltimore Colts to sneak off in the middle of the night and relocate the team to Indianapolis. I'm not going to praise sneaking away and being greedy. Not gonna happen. Are you telling me ABC wouldn't be supremely pissed that NBC stole away Grey's Anatomy? That's what this is. So, I don't blame Bravo. And for anyone who is thinking, who are the Colts? Broaden your horizons a bit, that's football!

But here we are, Project Runway starts its run on Lifetime. And I'll admit, I'm concerned. Let's run down why, shall we.

1. Commercials.

Is it just me or does this season seem extremely lackluster going by the previews? I hope I'm wrong, but I haven't seen one preview that contains smack talk, a hint of a fight or argument, just basically no drama. And I'm like, huh? And I feel like something should make it into the previews to sort of get people excited for the normal drama that unfolds during Project Runway.

2. Move to LA. and Too Many Celebrities.

There look to be more Hollywood guest judges than ever. Which may be because most notable designers aren't based in LA. UGH! I do not want this show to go more Hollywood. I do think the reputation would suffer for that (last season's increase was criticized as well). The designers are the best guest judges. Its a mistake to move this show away from the mecca of the fashion world and the location of Fashion Week.

Thus far I've see Lindsey Lohan, Christina Applegate, and Nicole Kidman all making appearances this season and I doubt the list ends there. Too Hollywood! This isn't exactly Sarah Jessica Parker presenting a challenge for the designers to design something within a tight budget for her line offered at Target.

4. Lifetime=Changing Demographic

I think its a problem to fit PR into the Lifetime mold and not have Lifetime roll with the punches where PR is concerned. You already have a contingent who are banning the move to Lifetime. So, I think it would be a problem to just diminish the dramatic side. The producers are the same. But the network is different and they approve and edit what goes on as well. And Lifetime doesn't have a show airing at midnight showing swimmer's asses, cursing, and drinking on TV (Watch What Happens).

I am skeptical that Lifetime can create the same online community that Bravo did, and the commercials with everyone yelling and the Lifetime website don't make me think differently about that. Having said all that, I hope its the PR I know and love, but man do those previews leave me wondering if this is going to be an off season.

And along with that, Lifetime features a completely different demographic than Bravo. And plain and simple, Lifetime is not the network of young trendsetters. I hope that the show is not tamed down to work better with Army Wives and Disease of the Week movies. But I fear it may be and it won't be the same appealing show we know and love.

So, we'll see. I do see it as a problem that there is no drama in the commercials. And I'm not talking knock down drag out fights. That's not something that happens on PR. I haven't heard one catty comment, which for PR is what drama is (you know of the "that's a hot tranny mess "variety). Words are the weapon, commentary is what contributes to the drama and there's been none in the commercials.


I'm skeptical, but I'm hoping when I tune in tonight, its going to be the same Project Runway I know and love. But first, don't forget to watch the All Star Project Runway that airs before the season premiere. Its got several favorite designers returning (Daniel V, Mychael, Korto, Chris) and a heinous one as well (I'm talking to you, Jeffrey!).

Tuesday, March 04, 2008

Project Runway: Comments on Part One of Season Finale

Wasn't happy that Rami won. And I think this was emphasized by the fact that I don't know that Rami should really be a part of this competition. Rami is clearly already established and a name and has celebrity clientele, which is really, to me, not what the show is for, I think of the show as launching an unknown. Chloe (Season 2 winner) had a store in Houston, but I think that's quite a bit different than having an LA studio with your name out front where you design (and have had your clothes on the red carpet).

Now, if I here one more word about Chris being a costume designer, I'm going to strangle someone. This also reminds me of something I dislike seeing on a competition like Project Runway. Best way I can describe this is to use America's Next Top Model as an example. On there, in the first few seasons when I watched, they have had a couple of plus size models in the running, but when it comes down to it, they always hold it against them that they are plus size models. Either you are willing to take a chance, which they did by choosing them for the final group, or they aren't, but once they are on there, I don't want to continue to hear about it in such a negative way. It never gives them a chance.

Also, I'm not sure why everyone is so freaked by the use of human hair. Hair extensions are not something uncommon anymore, and the judges in their blogs seemed to think they wouldn't have been as turned off it had been synthetic hair. If you know hair, really know hair, you can tell the difference between synthetic hair and human hair, and the synthetic does not lay as nicely. I wasn't creeped out by it, and think the use of it was overblown (and used as an excuse to justify not choosing Chris).

I've seen it said on the Bravo boards and its worth repaeting. I think they did this last show and the showdown between Chris and Rami, so they'd have a reason to pick Rami over Chris. Roberto Cavalli picked Chris, which means Chris should have been in. Remember in Season 1 when Nancy O'Dell chose Wendy's dress and she was therefore in? Well, same thing based on what they've done this season (guest judge, whether wearing the design themselves or not, gets final say), should have happened. If Chris was going to be who they put through to the final 3, then they could have done that in the last episode. Rami still would have gotten to do his collection and show, just not on the show, but they wanted him there bad enough to do all this. If you read the blogs on Bravo (Michael Kors, Nina Garcia, Tim Gunn), its like they knew this ep was a little contrived and made excuses for not picking Chris, more so than overwhelming reasons for choosing Rami. Not happy about this.

I liked both collections but found Chris' more innovative. Also, thought it ironic that the judges raved over Rami's draped dress when that was him showing the same thing over again. That dress was gorgeous, but I expected it to be. That heavy jacket didn't work and that black dress didn't work with those side circles.

Still love Rami and wish him the best, but thought Chris should have been in the final 3 based on those 3 piece collections.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Quarterlife - Anyone Watch the Premiere?

The show about the quarterlife crisis. Did anyone watch it either online or on TV?

I really enjoyed it but I too am going through a quarterlife crisis. I can, however see others getting annoyed with the main girl. And the way she screwed her friends was wrong, but clearly necessary to set up the relationships and dynamics that will make up the show. I found her less annoying as the hour went by, though her meek pronouncement at the staff meeting bugged the heck out of me.

The biggest problem I truly see with the show is that I wonder if this was the cast used for the original pitch in 2005 to the networks during Pilot season. I would guess not. I think this was cast with intentions of the internet, and that might affect its mainstream appeal. When Bree Turner is the most recognizable name (I think), that's says it all.

If anyone remembers a show in the late 90s on ABC called Wasteland, this reminds me of that, but with better writing. But Wasteland had a more known and visually appealing cast (which included Brad Rowe, Rebecca Gayheart, and Sasha Alexander). If they took the writing of this and some of that cast, this would have gotten better ratings. Also, the lighting on the show screams low budget. I don't mind it, but others might.


UPDATE: NBC has already jumped ship and bailed on this show due to the low ratings. Don't think that was appropriate or necessary. When you don't advertise a show, it's already aired online, and had some sort of premiere on MTV, I wouldn't expect a blockbuster ratings night. But, not even airing a second episode doesn't allow for the correction of your poor advertising efforts to allow for word of mouth and other buzz to spread to get a ratings bump. Plus, I question the accuracy of the ratings, I wouldn't say your typical Nielsen family covers everyone who would watch this show. NBC is (currently) planning to air the remaining episodes on Bravo.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Project Runway - Who Will Win This Season?

Will it be Chris, Rami, Christian or Jillian? I don't think we can predict who will win. They tend to actually pick off of what is shown during Fashion Week since the 3 they put forward tend to be ones they think are talented enough to do something special in design.

I have purposely avoided watching their shows, so I am saying this without knowing how the lines were. The reason I say it's hard to predict, is that if you remember, in Season 2, Daniel V was the young innovative designer (like Christian and was also a judge favorite - I think he won more often than Christian), who we all expected an amazing show from, and it fell flat. It was his to lose, and he lost it. I'm not saying Christian (or anyone else) won't deliver, but after Daniel V's showing, I'm not totally certain that we can go off of what we have seen from the show because something seems to happen in those 2 months. We can also be surprised in a good way at the Fashion Week shows. As much as I loved Jay McCarroll during Season 1, I didn't know his line was going to be that fantastic, it was just a great surprise.

I will say, that for the first time, I won't be mad that any of the 4 win. My least favorite of the final group is Jillian, but I certainly don't hate her, just find her mildly annoying and whiny at times. But, I wouldn't be devastated if she won, unlike in years past, when there was someone who I just hated and didn't want to win. I'm definitely looking forward to seeing four great lines that makes the final decision of who wins Project Runway very difficult.